AGM - Chairman & MD Addresses and presentation slides
Released
Released
Announcement PDF
23 October 2023
Company Announcements
ASX Limited
20 Bridge Street
SYDNEY NSW 2000
Annual General Meeting 2023
Please find attached the Chairman’s Address, Managing Director’s Address and
the accompanying presentation slides for today’s Annual General Meeting of
Argo Investments Limited (ASX: ARG).
Yours faithfully,
Tim Binks
Company Secretary
Argo Investments Limited
ACN 007 519 520
invest@argoinvesments.com.au
argoinvestments.com.au
Head Office
Level 25, 91 King William St
Adelaide SA 5000
08 8210 9500
Sydney Office
Level 37, 259 George St
Sydney NSW 2000
02 8274 4700
2023 Annual General Meeting
Chairman’s Address
Delivered by Mr. Russell Higgins AO at the 77th Annual General Meeting of Argo
Investments Limited (Argo or Company) at the Adelaide Convention Centre on Monday
23 October 2023 at 10.00am.
Full year profit results
Last financial year was characterised by market volatility and challenging
macroeconomic conditions. The global economy was impacted as Governments
and Central Banks unwound the emergency fiscal and monetary policies adopted
during the pandemic and as supply chains began to recover from the severe
disruptions. Inflation re-emerged as a challenge for world economies and for
policy makers. In this environment Argo Investments again delivered a positive
total return for shareholders, including record high annual fully franked
dividends.
Argo’s 2023 full year profit of $271.7 million represents an increase of +8.2%
over the previous year, excluding the one-off, non-cash income received in the
prior reporting period. A number of companies in Argo’s investment portfolio
increased their dividends which bolstered our income. However, these higher
dividends were partially offset by lower dividends received from BHP and Rio
Tinto, reflecting weaker commodity prices, particularly for iron ore.
Record fully franked dividends
In August, the Board was pleased to declare a fully franked final dividend of 18.0
cents per share. Together with Argo’s interim dividend of 16.5 cents per share,
annual fully franked dividends totalled 34.5 cents per share – an increase of
+4.5%.
Significantly, both the interim and the final fully franked dividends for the 2023
financial year marked record highs for the Company.
We have now paid dividends every year since Argo was founded in 1946 and it is
worth noting that only a handful of Australian listed companies can boast a
record of delivering dividends to shareholders for 77 consecutive years.
Argo Investments Limited
ACN 007 519 520
invest@argoinvestments.com.au
argoinvestments.com.au
Head Office
Level 25, 91 King William St
Adelaide SA 5000
08 8210 9500
Sydney Office
Level 37, 259 George St
Sydney NSW 2000
02 8274 4700
Furthermore, since the introduction of Australia’s imputation system in 1987,
every dividend has had franking credits attached and since 1995, all dividends
have been fully franked.
We are proud of this enviable track record and remain focused on providing our
shareholders with sustainable and tax-effective fully franked dividends, together
with capital growth.
Investment performance
Over the 12 months to 30 September 2023, Argo’s investment performance, as
measured by net tangible assets (NTA) return after management expenses and
adjusted for the corporate tax we pay, was +13.1%. This compares to the
S&P/ASX 200 Accumulation Index which gained +13.5%, noting that the Index
does not make allowance for any costs.
The slight underperformance relative to the Index reflects investor sentiment
pivoting back to growth-style investments. Argo’s investment process favours
more mature businesses that can maintain and grow their dividends. Taking a
longer-term view, over the three financial years since the COVID pandemic, Argo
has outperformed the Index return of +11.0% per annum, delivering +11.8% per
annum.
Directorate
I informed shareholders at last year’s AGM that the Board had developed a
succession plan to refresh the Board whilst maintaining an appropriate mix of
skills, experience and diversity. Retirements and new appointments are being
staggered over time to ensure our long-serving Non-executive Directors are not
all retiring simultaneously. The first elements of the succession plan were
implemented in the period leading up to last year’s AGM and you will recall that
Anne Brennan retired at the conclusion of that Meeting.
Since then, on 30 September 2023, Roger Davis retired from the Board after 11
years of service, including as Chair of the Remuneration Committee. Roger
joined Argo’s Board in 2012, bringing experience as a director of numerous ASXlisted companies and a strong background in financial services, including
executive roles in banking and investment banking, and as Chairman of Bank of
Queensland. As an active member of the Board and applying his skills and
insights, Roger helped guide Argo through various market cycles and events,
including the global pandemic.
On behalf of the Board, I would like to thank Roger for his diligent contribution to
Argo Investments.
argoinvestments.com.au | 2
Following these retirements, two new Directors have been appointed.
Peter Warne was appointed as an independent, Non-executive Director with
effect from 1 November 2022. Peter is an experienced company director and has
extensive knowledge of the financial services and investment banking sectors.
His executive career included senior positions at Bankers Trust Australia and,
among his director roles, was the Chairman of Macquarie Group.
Melissa Holzberger was appointed as an independent, Non-executive Director
with effect from 1 October 2023. She is a commercial, energy and resources
lawyer with considerable experience in the international energy and resources
sector. Melissa is an experienced director currently serving on various ASXlisted company boards and has previously been a member of numerous other
public, government and not-for-profit boards.
I am pleased to formally introduce Peter and Melissa to shareholders today. They
are standing for election to the Board and you will hear from each of them later in
the meeting.
Shareholder survey results
We recently conducted an online survey of our shareholders. The purpose was to
better understand our shareholders and how we can improve our communication
and engagement.
We would like to share the key findings of the survey with you today:
• Almost two thirds of respondents have been Argo shareholders for 10 or more
years;
• One third have been shareholders for 20 or more years;
• Diversified exposure to Australia’s share market is the most important reason
shareholders hold Argo shares, followed by fully franked dividends;
• 95% of shareholders are happy with the current quantity of information
provided;
• Emails are by far the most popular form of communication, with 80% of
shareholders nominating emails as their preferred method of accessing
information about the Company;
• 80% of respondents rated our shareholder engagement as ‘excellent’ or ‘very
good’; and
• 97% of our shareholders would recommend Argo to other investors.
argoinvestments.com.au | 3
Thank you to all those who completed the survey. We are pleased with the level
of support for Argo among our shareholders. However, we do not see these
results as cause for complacency. We remain cognisant that Argo is owned by,
and managed for the benefit of, our shareholders and we will continue to work
hard to serve your interests.
We welcome feedback at any time. If you have suggestions for Argo, including
our shareholder engagement, please be in touch. Contact details will be provided
at the end of today’s presentation.
Outlook
Australia’s economy continues to be shaped largely by macroeconomic
influences, most notably persistently high inflation. Like many central banks
around the world, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) has aggressively raised
interest rates in an effort to dampen demand and control price rises.
To the surprise of many, Australia’s economy remains remarkably resilient as
evidenced by robust employment figures and rising house prices. An economic
‘soft landing’ seems possible as the RBA navigates the narrow path of lowering
inflation, while not tipping the economy into recession.
However, the positive overall state of the economy belies the growing financial
pressures on many people due to sharp interest rate increases and the growing
cost of everyday expenses. In turn, this is weighing heavily on consumer
confidence and spending.
Although investor sentiment is indicating that the Australian and global economy
should be able to avoid recession, there are risks to the outlook. Geopolitical
tensions and risks are particularly heightened at present. As a result, growth
may be subdued in the near to medium term and further share market volatility is
likely.
Against this backdrop, I want to remind and reassure shareholders that, for more
than three quarters of a century, Argo has navigated through varying conditions
including different market cycles and disruptive events. We have done this
through being disciplined and consistently applying our conservative, long-term
investment approach.
Argo has no debt, cash on hand and a portfolio of quality stocks, ensuring we are
well-positioned in the current investment environment.
argoinvestments.com.au | 4
Thank you
I would like to conclude my formal remarks today by thanking our Managing
Director, Jason Beddow, and the Argo team for their ongoing hard work.
I would also like to thank my fellow Board members for their valuable
contributions over the last year.
Finally, on behalf of the Board, I warmly thank our loyal shareholders. To our new
shareholders, welcome to Argo.
argoinvestments.com.au | 5
2023 Annual General Meeting
Managing Director’s Address
Delivered by Mr. Jason Beddow at the 77th Annual General Meeting of Argo Investments
Limited (Argo or Company) held at the Adelaide Convention Centre on Monday 23 October
2023 at 10.00am (Adelaide time).
Market review
Only a short time ago, the prospect of a global recession seemed likely, as
central banks aggressively raised interest rates to control rampant inflation.
However, indicators are increasingly now pointing to an economic ‘soft landing.’
So far, economies are successfully navigating the narrow path of lowering
inflation through tightening monetary policy, without causing a recession.
In the US, the Federal Reserve has raised rates more quickly than at any time
since the 1980s. Australia has also followed suit, with twelve rate increases in
quick succession totalling 4.0%. The official cash rate is now 4.1% and, while
further increases are possible, we believe we are near the top for interest rates in
the current cycle.
Like many other developed economies, Australia’s economic resilience has been
largely underpinned by fiscal stimulus and historically low unemployment. In
addition, many Australians are benefiting from higher deposit rates, savings
levels, and asset prices.
Over the financial year to 30 June 2023, Australia’s share market defied most
expectations to perform strongly in the face of this persistent inflation, a sombre
global economic outlook and the steepest interest rate increases in recent
history.
All industry sectors generated positive returns, although Technology was the
standout performer, surging more than +30%. Companies leveraged to lithium
and other battery minerals also generated particularly strong returns.
Meanwhile, sectors with more defensive attributes, such as Utilities and Health
Care, lagged the broader market.
Argo Investments Limited
ACN 007 519 520
invest@argoinvestments.com.au
argoinvestments.com.au
Head Office
Level 25, 91 King William St
Adelaide SA 5000
08 8210 9500
Sydney Office
Level 37, 259 George St
Sydney NSW 2000
02 8274 4700
Following this strong performance, Australian investors seem less certain as we
entered the new financial year. For the first three months to 30 September 2023,
the S&P/ASX 200 Accumulation Index fell -0.8%. Energy was the best
performing sector for the quarter, up +11.2% in contrast to Healthcare which
continues to be weak, down -8.6% and Consumer Staples down -5.9%.
Investment portfolio
We have been calling the investment environment “uncertain” for what feels like
some time now. Reflecting these conditions, companies provided very little
forward guidance during the recent August reporting season. I will elaborate on
some of the key points from company profits results a little later.
We continue to see this uncertainty playing out in the underperformance of many
smaller capitalised companies, as they are more likely to be impacted by higher
costs, less scale, and a slowing consumer.
We diversify our portfolio to maintain balanced performance over longer time
frames and deliver shareholders a relatively smooth dividend profile through
market cycles.
We have largely been adding to existing holdings and reducing the overall
number of holdings in the portfolio, although we have recently added one new
stock to the portfolio, Resmed, which I will discuss shortly.
We have also exited two takeover targets: Liontown Resources at the Albemarle
bid price of $3.00 per share and Estia Health following the final dividend
payment which exhausted their franking credit balance. In addition, we have
exited our holding in Insurance Australia Group and sold down positions in
Brambles, Helia Group and Diversified United Investment.
Proceeds from these sales have been redeployed into several stocks including
CSL, which we continue to believe is an excellent quality company and now
trading at more attractive levels than previously, at a time when it is returning to
double digit profit growth.
We also increased our holding in Viva Energy following major shareholder Vitol’s
selldown of 16% of the company. We think Viva’s prospects remain strong. An
ACCC ruling on its proposed purchase of the South Australian-based “On the Run”
chain of petrol stations and convenience stores is pending.
We recently participated in a $750 million equity raising by APA Group to partly
fund its acquisition of Alinta’s Pilbara assets, which included a portfolio of
conventional and renewable assets, including a development pipeline of wind,
solar and battery generation.
argoinvestments.com.au | 2
Resmed (ASX code: RMD)
Resmed is the world leader in Continuous Positive Airway Pressure (CPAP)
therapy, the recommended treatment for the majority of patients with
obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA).
OSA is a sleep-related breathing disorder causing complete or partial
obstruction of a person’s airflow. The brain senses the impaired breathing,
causing the individual to subconsciously rouse from sleep to reopen their airway.
Resmed manufactures and distributes CPAP machines. These are ventilators
which deliver a continuous stream of pressurised air through a mask while the
patient sleeps.
Because obesity is a leading cause of sleep apnoea, the recent hype around GLP1 ‘weight loss’ drugs and speculation they are a ‘cure all’ for addressing obesity
has led investors to conclude these medications will cannibalise or displace
CPAP devices as a first line therapy for OSA.
This is reflected in Resmed’s share price which is down more than 30% since 30
June. In our view, the potentially positive impacts of these weight loss drugs are
overstated. We have listened to dozens of calls from medical experts, both
positive and sceptical. The full impacts will not be known for many years.
Factoring in the possible negative impacts on Resmed’s sales if obesity declines
globally, we still believe that at these share price levels it represents a good
buying opportunity.
August reporting season
Prior to the Covid-19 disruptions, a large percentage of listed companies
provided guidance on forward earnings. Currently very few companies give
guidance. More commonly they give trading updates at AGMs and investor days.
Considering this, I wanted to give our insights from the most recent reporting
season.
Overall, profit results defied the gloomy expectations from earlier in the year,
given headwinds from the slowing economy and rising costs, especially labour,
insurance and interest costs. While revenues showed strength, this often came
from price increases rather than volume expansion. Declines in other input costs,
such as commodity prices and freight costs, also helped to ease margin
pressures.
Companies generally provided conservative guidance, if at all. This often
disappointed the market and saw consensus earnings downgrades for
companies.
argoinvestments.com.au | 3
For the broader market, consensus earnings expectations were revised down by 2.4% during the month and now sit at -6.6% for the 2024 financial year.
Australian equities were soft in August and September, as lacklustre outlooks
from companies weighed on investors’ minds. Interestingly, August was one of
the most volatile earnings seasons in the past 15 years, with one in eight stocks
moving more than 10% up or down on the day of their result.
The escalating cost of debt is emerging as an issue, with higher interest
payments a growing challenge for companies with stretched balance sheets or
large refinancing needs. We believe this issue is being underestimated and could
result in further earnings downgrades over the next couple of years as
companies need to refinance cheaper debt.
August dividends were slightly disappointing, particularly from the large,
diversified miners, though not unexpected with lower commodity prices and
higher capital expenditure. On average, payout ratios are still well below the prepandemic average. However, we see a risk that payouts edge lower as companies
brace against a tougher economy, service higher interest costs and potentially
de-leverage their balance sheets.
Turning now to commentary from some of the bigger companies during reporting
season.
The Commonwealth Bank of Australia result was solid, despite Net Interest
Margin and cost pressures. Bad debts remain low in the banking sector but have
started to creep up in some non-bank lenders. There was evidence that
competitive pressures may be easing and, while there was an air of caution, there
was certainly no panic in the outlook comments from CBA.
Wesfarmers indicated no signs of weakness in their Bunnings or Kmart
businesses. Woolworths noted that demand remains solid, although there are
signs of customers switching to cheaper items. Fuel retailers Viva Energy and
Ampol reported seeing strong commercial demand for fuel and Domino’s noted
‘signs of life’ in demand for pizza.
Resource companies disappointed with operating cost pressures and labour
remaining a challenge. We are seeing further delays in project execution. We also
saw over $5 billion in impairments due to cost overruns across the industry,
including Rio’s Australian aluminium assets, South32, Alumina and Fortescue’s
iron ore business.
argoinvestments.com.au | 4
Global cyclicals benefited from the weak Australian Dollar. This group of stocks
was the only category that reported positive profit surprises in the June half. It
also had the lowest share of negative revisions for financial year 2024 earnings,
due to a combination of the higher quality of global cyclicals and the translation
benefit of the lower Australian Dollar.
Health Care had a mixed reporting season, as the sector continued to deal with
cost pressures, labour absenteeism and weaker utilisation of their services.
Some companies in the sector, such as Ramsay Health Care, are relatively highly
geared and saw a significant increase in interest costs.
REITs had a decent reporting season, although rising interest rates and the
expiration of interest hedges meant earnings declined for many Australian REITs.
Outlook
In comparison to most other countries, Australia’s economy is faring relatively
well. However, as we look ahead to next year, interest rate rises will likely have a
slowing impact on the economy.
It appears the first half of 2024 will be particularly weak, with economists
expecting the global economy to eke out GDP growth of just +1.7%. This
compares to this year’s predicted growth of +2.3%.
Geopolitical risks remain elevated. As we approach the two-year anniversary of
Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, there are few signs there will be a resolution to the
conflict. More recently, a significant increase in hostilities in the Middle East has
added to geopolitical tensions around the world.
Current investor sentiment indicates that Australia and the global economies
should be able to avoid recession. In our view, further share market volatility is
likely and evidence of the economy slowing will likely emerge, leading to
pressure on earnings.
High population growth, driven by immigration, should be a major economic
tailwind for Australia in the coming years. However, on a per capita basis the
growth does not look so impressive, which highlights the lack of productivity and
the challenges with migration exacerbating the housing shortage issue.
Residential housing availability and affordability are now key areas of community
concern.
With no debt, cash available and a diversified portfolio, Argo is well-positioned to
navigate these conditions, applying our conservative, long-term investment
approach.
argoinvestments.com.au | 5
Thank you
I would like to acknowledge the efforts of the whole Argo team this year. Our
staff continue to be fully committed to the success of the Company across both
our Adelaide and Sydney offices.
I also acknowledge the contribution from the Chairman and Non-executive
Directors. I welcome the new Directors to Argo, and I look forward to working
with them all as we best navigate Argo through this next period for you, our
shareholders. I would also like to personally thank Roger Davis for his
contribution to the Company.
I wish all our shareholders well for the remainder of the year. We thank you for
your continued support and I look forward to continuing the conversation with
you in 2024.
argoinvestments.com.au | 6
Annual
General Meeting
2023
Disclaimer
This presentation has been prepared by Argo Service Company Pty Ltd (ASCO) (ACN 603 367 479)
(Australian Financial Services Licence 470477), on behalf of Argo Investments Limited (ACN 007 519
520). ASCO’s Financial Services Guide is available on request or at argoinvestments.com.au.
This presentation contains unsolicited general information only, which does not take into account the
particular objectives, financial situation or needs of any individual investor. It is not intended to be
passed on or relied upon as a recommendation by any person.
Before making any decision about the information provided, an investor should consult their
independent adviser and consider the appropriateness of the information, having regard to their
objectives, financial situation and needs.
Past performance may not be indicative of future performance and no guarantee of future returns is
implied or given. While all reasonable care has been taken when preparing this presentation, no
responsibility is accepted for any loss, damage, cost or expense resulting directly or indirectly from
any error, omission or misrepresentation in the information presented.
3
Board of Directors
Russell Higgins AO
Non-executive Chairman
Jason Beddow
Managing Director
Melissa Holzberger
Non-executive Director
Lianne Buck
Non-executive Director
Chris Cuffe AO
Non-executive Director
Peter Warne
Non-executive Director
Liz Lewin
Non-executive Director
Our objective
To maximise long-term
shareholder returns through
reliable fully franked dividend
income and capital growth.
Actively managing a diversified
portfolio of Australian shares
with a low-cost, internally
managed business model, we
apply a conservative, long-term
investment approach which has
proven resilient since 1946.
5
2023 overview
Profit
Earnings per share Full year dividends
$271.7m
$36.1c
34.5c
$251.2m in 2022
(Excl. one-off, non-cash income)
34.3c per share in 2022
(Excl. one-off, non-cash income)
Fully franked per share
33.0c per share in 2022
Total assets
MER
Argo Shareholders
$6.9b
0.155%
95,600
$6.4b in 2022
(Management Expense Ratio)
0.141% in 2022
96,100 in 2022
Annual dividends cents per share
35
30
28
29.5
30.5
31
2015
2016
2017
31.5
33
33
30
34.5
28
25
20
15
10
5
0
2014
2018
Interim dividend
2019
2020
2021
2022
2023
Final dividend
7
Total returns
13.1%
13.5%
11.8%
11.0%
9.1%
5.6%
6.1%
6.7%
6.2%
6.8%
7.4%
2.2%
1 year
Total Shareholder Return (TSR)
3 years (pa)
5 years (pa)
NTA after management expenses
10 years (pa)
S&P/ASX 200 Accum. Index
Figures above are to 30 September 2023.
8
Shareholder returns $10,000 invested
$54,044
$38,865
$18,026
Share price
Plus dividends
Plus franking
Figures above are to 30 September 2023.
9
Roger Davis
BEc (Hons), MPhil (Oxon), FCPA
Retired Non-executive Director
10
Peter Warne
BA (Actuarial Studies), FAICD
Non-executive Director
11
Melissa Holzberger
BA, LLB, LLM (Resources Law), Dip International
Nuclear Law, GDLP, FGIA, GAICD
Non-executive Director
12
Shareholder
survey
Key survey findings
97%
20+ yrs
10+ yrs
Would recommend Argo
to other investors
One third have been
shareholders for 20+ years
Almost two thirds have been
shareholders for 10+ years
‘Excellent’ or
‘Very good’
Diversified
95%
80% rated our engagement as
‘excellent’ or ‘very good’
Top reason for owning Argo shares:
‘diversified exposure to ASX’
Happy with the amount of
information provided
Key findings
Looking ahead
15
Shareholder benefits
Low-cost,
internally managed
Experienced board and
management team
Long-term, proven
investment approach
Fully-franked,
sustainable dividends
Strong balance
sheet, no debt
Diversified and
administratively simple
16
Share market performance
140
130
S&P/ASX 200 & Accumulation Index
Before, during and post-pandemic
120
110
100
90
80
70
60
First
vaccine
released
US Fed
starts rate
RBA starts
rises
rate rises
RBA
pauses
rate rises
Figures above are to 30 September 2023.
18
Australian equities by industry
Australian share market performance by industry
3 months to 30 September 2023
15%
Energy
Consumer Discretionary
10%
Financials
Communication Services
5%
Utilities
Materials
0%
Industrials
Real Estate
-5%
Information Technology
Consumer Staples
Health Care
-10%
Source: Factset
19
Investment portfolio
Sector diversification
Top 10 holdings
Materials 15.7%
Other Financials 12.8%
Banks 12.4%
Health Care 10.9%
Consumer Staples 8.5%
Telcos & I.T. 8.2%
Energy 8.0%
Industrials 7.5%
Consumer Discret. 6.9%
Property 2.9%
LICs 2.5%
Utilities 1.9%
Macquarie Group
6.5%
BHP
6.1%
CSL
5.0%
CBA
4.1%
Wesfarmers
4.0%
Rio Tinto
3.7%
ANZ
3.2%
Santos
3.0%
Telstra
2.8%
Westpac
2.6%
Cash 1.8%
Figures are as at 30 September 2023.
20
Recent portfolio movements
Purchases
Sales
Since the end of the 2023 financial year.
21
Resmed (ASX code: RMD)
40
12-month share price performance
Cents
35
30
25
20
15
Source: Factset
22
Reporting season
Consensus earnings
Source: RIMES, IBES, Morgan Stanley Research. As at 31 August 2023.
24
Key takeouts
Cost of debt
escalating
Dividends slightly
disappointing
Consumer
demand solid
Bad debts
remain low
Global cyclicals
benefit from
weak A$
Cost pressures
increasing
Looking ahead
Share your feedback
Discover